Every Pokémon trainer remembers the moment they first stood before a wooden table or a generic briefcase, staring at three Poké Balls. It is the most consequential decision in any playthrough—a choice between Fire, Water, and Grass that dictates your early-game difficulty, your team’s aesthetic, and your late-game sweep potential.
But let’s be honest: not all starters are created equal. While Game Freak strives for balance, the history of the franchise is littered with clear victors—Pokémon that didn’t just win their generation's popularity contest, but dominated the competitive landscape and streamlined the single-player experience.
From the pixelated fields of Kanto to the sprawling wilderness of Paldea, here is the definitive ranking of the best starter from every generation. We aren't just looking at who looks the coolest; we’re looking at movepools, base stat totals (BST), Hidden Abilities, and historical impact.
Generation I: Squirtle, Bulbasaur, or Charmander? The Winner: Bulbasaur (Venusaur)
In the early days of Kanto, players were often blinded by the "Cool Factor" of a fire-breathing dragon. However, if we look at the mechanics of Pokémon Red, Blue, and Yellow, Bulbasaur is the undisputed king of efficiency.
Statistically, Venusaur was a monster in Generation I due to the "Special" stat not yet being split into Attack and Defense. Its high Special made it both a tank and a powerhouse. Furthermore, the early game of Kanto is famously hostile to Charmander (Brock and Misty) and neutral to Squirtle. Bulbasaur, however, trivializes the first two gyms and resists the third.
In the modern competitive era, Venusaur has maintained its lead thanks to the ability Chlorophyll. Under sun, Venusaur becomes one of the most terrifying sweepers in the game.
- ▹Sample Set (VGC/Singles):
- ▹Ability: Chlorophyll
- ▹Item: Life Orb / Focus Sash
- ▹Moves: Sleep Powder, Giga Drain, Weather Ball, Sludge Bomb.
Generation II: Chikorita, Cyndaquil, or Totodile? The Winner: Cyndaquil (Typhlosion)
Generation II is often criticized for its awkward level curve and the relative weakness of its starters compared to Kanto. However, Typhlosion stands out for its sheer offensive reliability.
While Totodile eventually becomes a beast in later generations with Dragon Dance and Sheer Force, in the original Gold, Silver, and Crystal, it suffered from the physical/special split not yet existing. Water was purely special, and Totodile was a physical attacker. Typhlosion, sharing the exact same base stats as Charizard but without the crippling 4x weakness to Stealth Rock (which didn't exist yet anyway), was the premier special attacker of Johto. Its access to Flamethrower and Thunder Punch (which was Special in Gen II) gave it coverage most other Fire types envied.
Generation III: Treecko, Torchic, or Mudkip? The Winner: Mudkip (Swampert)
"So I herd u like Mudkips" wasn't just a meme; it was a warning. Swampert is arguably one of the most balanced and powerful starters ever designed. Its Water/Ground typing provides a massive advantage: it is only weak to Grass. In a region like Hoenn, which is famously "too much water," a Ground-type that can also surf is a godsend.
Swampert’s bulk (100 HP / 90 Def / 90 SpD) allowed it to survive almost any neutral hit, and its Mega Evolution in Gen VI turned it into a Rain-team terror with Swift Swim. Whether it’s setting up Stealth Rocks or hitting a STAB Earthquake, Swampert is the MVP of Hoenn.
Generation IV: Turtwig, Chimchar, or Piplup? The Winner: Chimchar (Infernape)
Sinnoh is a harsh region with a notorious lack of Fire-type options (unless you picked Ponyta, you were stuck). This made Chimchar almost mandatory for a balanced playthrough. But Infernape isn't just a winner by default; it is a mechanical masterclass.
With 108 Base Speed and 104 in both Attack and Special Attack, Infernape was the original "Mixed Attacker" king. It boasted a movepool that felt illegal: Close Combat, Flare Blitz, U-turn, Mach Punch, and even Grass Knot to deal with heavy Water types. In the Diamond/Pearl competitive era, an Infernape lead was a terrifying "Lead" that could fake out opponents or set up hazards with ease.
Generation V: Snivy, Tepig, or Oshawott? The Winner: Snivy (Serperior)
Regrettably, the Unova starters are often considered the weakest trio in terms of design and initial gameplay impact. Emboar was a slow, "glass cannon" fire/fighting type (the third in a row), and Samurott lacked a clear niche.
However, Serperior eventually rose to god-tier status thanks to its Hidden Ability: Contrary. This ability reverses stat changes. Suddenly, Leaf Storm—a high-damage move that usually lowers the user's Special Attack—became a boost. Every time Serperior used its strongest move, it got stronger. This single mechanic turned a mediocre Grass type into a snowballing sweeper that could dismantle entire teams in the higher tiers of Smogon play.
Generation VI: Chespin, Fennekin, or Froakie? The Winner: Froakie (Greninja)
There is no contest here. Greninja is perhaps the most influential starter in the history of the franchise, both in the anime and the competitive scene. Its Hidden Ability, Protean, allows it to change its type to the move it is about to use, giving it STAB (Same Type Attack Bonus) on everything.
Greninja’s versatility was so overwhelming that it was eventually banned to the "Uber" tier in competitive circles during its prime. Whether utilizing a Choice Specs loaded with Hydro Pump and Dark Pulse, or a physical set with Gunk Shot to surprise Fairy types, Greninja was the ultimate ninja.
The Greninja Advantage: 1. Speed: At 122 Base Speed, it outpaces almost the entire unboosted meta. 2. Movepool: Access to Spikes, Toxic Spikes, and Taunt made it a premier "Utility" offensive threat. 3. Battle Bond: The Ash-Greninja form added further raw power for those who participated in the Sun/Moon demo.
Generation VII: Rowlet, Litten, or Popplio? The Winner: Litten (Incineroar)
If you follow the VGC (Video Game Championships) scene, you already knew this was coming. Incineroar is not just the best Gen VII starter; it is arguably the best Pokémon in the history of doubles format.
Why? One word: Intimidate. When Incineroar enters the field, it lowers the Attack of both opponents. Combined with his access to Fake Out (to flinch an opponent), Parting Shot (to lower stats and switch out), and Flare Blitz/Darkest Lariat for damage, Incineroar provides more "role compression" than any other creature in the game. It’s a tank, a debuffer, and a pivot all in one muscular, feline package.
Generation VIII: Grookey, Scorbunny, or Sobble? The Winner: Grookey (Rillaboom)
In Sword and Shield, the "hidden ability power creep" reached its peak. Rillaboom was granted Grassy Surge, which automatically sets up Grassy Terrain upon entry. This doesn't just boost its Grass moves and provide passive healing; it enables Grassy Glide.
In Generation VIII, Grassy Glide had +1 Priority in Grassy Terrain. This meant Rillaboom could hit incredibly hard before the opponent could even move. Alongside its Gigantamax form, Rillaboom became a staple of almost every high-level competitive team, providing terrain control that countered the oppressive Psychic Terrain teams of the time.
Generation IX: Sprigatito, Fuecoco, or Quaxly? The Winner: Fuecoco (Skeledirge)
Paldea’s starters are remarkably well-balanced, but Skeledirge takes the crown for its sheer "Unaware" brilliance. In a generation defined by the Terastal mechanic and heavy setup sweepers, Skeledirge’s Hidden Ability Unaware allows it to ignore the opponent's stat boosts.
Furthermore, its signature move, Torch Song, is arguably the best starter signature move ever created. It is an 80-power Fire move that guarantees a Special Attack boost every time it is used. Skeledirge becomes bulkier and stronger the longer it stays on the field, making it a nightmare for physical attackers to break through.
- ▹Standard Skeledirge Utility:
- ▹Ability: Unaware
- ▹Moves: Torch Song, Will-O-Wisp, Slack Off, Hex/Earth Power.
Comparing the Legends: Who is the Star of Stars?
While each generation has its winner, some winners are "more winning" than others. If we were to create a "Hall of Fame" for the starters that fundamentally changed how Pokémon is played, the list would look like this:
- 1.Incineroar: For its absolute dominance of the VGC format across three consecutive generations.
- 2.Greninja: For proving that a starter could be "too good" for standard competitive play.
- 3.Venusaur: For its longevity and role as the original weather-abusing sweeper.
- 4.Swampert: For its near-perfect defensive profile and utility.
The Strategy Behind the Choice
When picking a starter, most casual players look at the final evolution's design. However, the expert look focuses on three pillars:
- ▹Typing Synergies: Dual typing is almost always superior to mono-typing. Starters like Swampert (Water/Ground) and Infernape (Fire/Fighting) excel because they cover their own weaknesses or gain vital new STAB coverage.
- ▹Actionable Speed: In Pokémon, moving first is often the difference between a win and a loss. Greninja and Infernape dominated because they lived in the high-speed tiers.
- ▹Hidden Abilities: Prior to Generation V, starters were mostly defined by their base stats. Now, a starter is only as good as its Hidden Ability. Liberty was taken with Rillaboom and Serperior precisely because their abilities (Grassy Surge and Contrary) transformed them from "fine" to "top-tier."
Final Thoughts
The beauty of Pokémon is that every starter is "viable" for a standard playthrough. You can beat Pokémon Emerald with Sceptile just as easily as you can with Swampert if you have the right supporting cast. But when we look at the data—the tournament usage, the movepool depth, and the ease of use—the winners listed above represent the gold standard of their respective regions.
Whether you prefer the utility of Incineroar or the sheer sweeping power of Serperior, these Pokémon represent the pinnacle of what a partner can be. So, next time you’re standing at that table in the professor's lab, remember: choose wisely. You aren't just picking a pet; you’re picking the foundation of your legacy.
Enjoyed this?
Share it with another Trainer.